Find Historic Hotels in New York, NY

"Considering the property is so close to Time Square, it's location was perfect and didn't feel congested. In addition, the staff was excellent, the property is newly renovated and rooms are large by NYC standards. One drawback is some of the rooms face the light shaft in the middle of the building, but it's NYC and you don't get everything. A+ Property and Staff!"

"The property is in a good location in the middle of time Square. However, it is old and rundown. Definitely needs updating. "

"Staff was SO kind and accommodating. Bathroom needs some attention. We read a review saying the water pressure wasn’t good but it was fantastic for us. This isn’t the fault of the staff but the hallway smelled very intensely of weed and cigarette smoke. "

"Breakfast 👌"

"Small but clean room .friendly staff."

"Clean Rooms"

"Hotel St.James is a small, quiet hotel. The room was small but comfortable. The location is phenomenal. There are two subway stations within a 4 minute walk and the 42nd Street Times Square subway station is within a 15 min walk. The air conditioner is a window mounted unit and is very loud and moderately functional. Housekeeping kept the room spotless and well stocked. Housekeeping was provided every day. Lyceum theater is literally feet from the hotel entrance. Several other theaters are easily within walking distance . There is a market next door to the hotel called Cook Market that provides an affordable alternative to expensive restaurants. The market has premade sandwiches, wraps, deserts, a hot line, a fruit line an area where fresh sandwiches are made. The food is very good. There is a dining room on top of the market so you can take food away for eat upstairs. I visited at lunch time and there must have been 30 people in the market getting lunch. You know it’s good when locals eat there. I utilized the market for 2 meals during the 6 days that I stayed in NYC."

"Location was great! Steakhouse was amazing. Rooms were nice. Only thing that looked a llittle tired and rundown were the hallways on the room floors. "

"Very nice art deco hotel. Wonderful staff and great location."