Search Resorts in Lower Matecumbe Key

"The room was spacious and had a feather bed that was almost too soft. A/C was good, and we really liked having a ceiling fan too. Shower was huge! But not a shelf or place to put a bar of soap or hang a washcloth. The laminate floors were very dirty, which we didn't notice until after taking showers and then getting into bed, had to get soap & water and wash them bedside, after that we just kept sandals on while in the room. The pool at Dockside (off site building) was wonderful and the pool at the main building was zero depth entry and oceanside and provided gorgeous sunset views! The on site restaurant was good and we had appetizers; drinks and breakfast there. Sadly we didn't use the offered kayaks; bikes; and paddle boards as we didn't have enough time! Still excellent to have them available to use. Highly recommend."

"Everything was lovely! Staff checked in daily via text which i think is a nice touch, the beach and pool areas were readily available with chairs and towels and our villa was so cute with everything you could need in a little kitchen and bathroom. Breakfast was from 6a-10a and it was what you'd expect plus a made to order omelette station. During the day they had someone there making a few select cocktails. The lobby also had most things you could probably need for purchase if you forgot something at home. Me and my husband went for our mini honeymoon and a nice little get away to the keys at chesapeake was also we could ask for."

"The apartment is a good size, but the cleaning needs improvement—especially sofa bed linens, which did not feel fresh.” Overall, the apartment is well-equipped and has everything you need. I would rate it four stars.”"

"Clean room, beautiful property."

"Love everything "

"The staff, place, everything was great. Just some irrationals guest let children play and screening around …3 am.. believe me 3:00 am.. l couldn’t believe. Children under 11-10 years old play and yelling around 3:00 am.. ridiculous !! "

"Older resort and needs updating but for the three nights we stayed it was comfortable. Stayed in a studio which had a kitchen area with full fridge and the room was large with a nice balcony overlooking the water. With low tide and prevailing winds you do smell the mangrove but it did not hinder our stay in the room. Staff is very friendly and accommodating. They had bikes available as well as (older) kayaks and a canoe. Chaise lounges in the pool area are not the most comfortable but it was still pleasant to spend time there. Skip Snappers next door and go to Snooks for a good meal. "

"Such a quaint place! It’s not new but definitely worth checking it out! The people are awesome too!"

"Property was truly beautiful with friendly staff and amazing amenities. The free shuttle to the other resorts was a great surprise as well. We took the Rum Runner for breakfast (shout out to Captain Dave and Bruce for being amazing). In my opinion, Amara Cay was the nicest of the three resorts if you’re looking for island luxury and a truly relaxing experience. Will definitely be visiting again!"